Jump to content

Subway - What If?


VWM

Recommended Posts


  • Replies 6.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

(1) No service between 96 and 14 St.

(2) No service between 96 and Chambers St.

(3) Suspended

(4) Extended to New Lots Avenue.

(7) No trains south of Hunterspoint Av

(A)(D) Uptown trains stop at 72 St.

(B) Extended to Coney Island via Brighton Local.

(N) No trains between Whitehall St and 59 St/Lex. Transfer between sections via the (4)(5).

(Q) Suspended. Use (B)(N) service.

(R) Trains run via the (D) from Atlantic Av to 47/50, then via the (F) to 36 St (Queens).

(S) Suspended

 

 

NEXT

Canal St (J)(N)(Q)(R)(6) closed and impassable. The (4)(5) tracks are unaffected however.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(1) No service between 96 and 14 St.

(2) No service between 96 and Chambers St.

(3) Suspended

(4) Extended to New Lots Avenue.

(7) No trains south of Hunterspoint Av

A D Uptown trains stop at 72 St.

B Extended to Coney Island via Brighton Local.

N No trains between Whitehall St and 59 St/Lex. Transfer between sections via the 4 5.

Q Suspended. Use B N service.

R Trains run via the D from Atlantic Av to 47/50, then via the F to 36 St (Queens).

S Suspended

 

 

NEXT

Canal St J N Q R 6 closed and impassable. The 4 5 tracks are unaffected however.

 

(J) No service between Essex Street and Broad Street, use (4)(5) INSTEAD

(N) No service between 34 street-Herald Square and Coney Island, use (B) INSTEAD

(Q) No service between Astoria-Ditmars and Prospect Park , use (S) to (2)(3)(4)(5) instead

(R) via (D) from Dekalb Avenue to W.4 street, then (F) to Roosevelt

(6) express in both directions 14 street- Brooklyn Bridge. Extended to Atlantic Avenue every other train

(B) stops at Dekalb, then via 4 Avenue, then Sea Beach, TO Coney Island

(D) STOPS AT Dekalb Avenue

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Canal St (J)(N)(Q)(R)(6) closed and impassable. The (4)(5) tracks are unaffected however.

 

 

(J)(Z) Esssex St to Jamaica Center (Nassau Express Peak)

(N) 34th Street to Astoria Ditmars (Broadway/Astoria Local)

(Q) Brighton Beach to Prospect Park (Brighton Local)

(D) via 4th Av Local

(B) via West End Brighton Beach to 47/50 Sts in both directions (West End Express Peak/4th Av Local), then normal route

(S) Franklin to Kings Hwy (Brighton Express)

(6)<6> Lexington Av Express until 14 St

(R) Bay Ridge Shuttle (4th Avenue Express)

Yellow (S) Pacific Street to Coney Island (4th Avenue Express/Sea Beach Local)

 

Additional Information

Yellow (S) runs Local between 59 St and 36 St in both directions, and Express to Pacific St

(R) trains run Express between 59 St and 36 St in both directions

(S) runs 6 Car consist

(B) trains run through Coney Island on the (Q), then merge onto the (D)

Downtown (B) trains stop at DeKalb Avenue

 

 

If I missed something, do not hesitate to tell me.

Edited by trainguy97
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXTCanal St (J)(N)(Q)(R)(6) closed and impassable. The (4)(5) tracks are unaffected however.

 

(6) runs express from 42nd Street and are extended to Bowling Green.

 

(J) terminate at Essex Street OR Bowery.

 

(N) runs in two sections:

Coney Island to Whitehall Street via the tunnel

34th Street and Ditmars Boulevard

 

(R) runs in two sections:

 

95th Street to Whitehall Street via the tunnel

34th Street to 71st-Continental

 

Use the (4)/ (5)/ (6) at Brooklyn Bridge to replace the (J) between Canal and Broad Street and the (N) and (R) between Canal and Whitehall (special OOS transfer available at Bowling Green/Whitehall). (4)/ (5) then run normal in Brooklyn.

 

(Q) runs Coney Island-Fulton Street via the Montauge tunnel. At Broad and Fulton Street, the first five cars open first, then after they are closed, the train moves forward enough to bring the rear cars into the station and then the rear five cars open (Fulton is the last stop). (Q) then runs light to Chambers and turns using the old Manny B lead tracks.

 

(D) STOPS at DeKalb Avenue, but otherwise, all 6th Avenue lines run their normal routes.

 

 

NEXT:

 

A bomb threat inside Grand Central has disrupted east side and (7) subway service.

Edited by Wallyhorse
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes.

 

(4) No service between 86 St and Brooklyn Bridge. The last stop on some southbound trains is 149 St. The last stop on some northbound trains is Bowling Green (wrong-rail via the loop to relay) or Wall St (use crossover).

(5) Runs via the (2) in both directions between 149 St and Nevins St.

(6) No service south of 59 St. The last stop on some southbound trains is 86 St.

(7) No trains south of Hunterspoint Av. Passengers are encouraged to transfer at Queensboro Plaza to the (N)(Q).

<7> No peak express service. Use (7).

(S) Suspended obviously.

 

NEXT

Clark St (2)(3) is impassable. Challenge: you can introduce no more than one additional transfer for people who normally take the (2)(3).

 

Please take TPH into account. Wallyhorse: you can't fit the (4)(5)(6) (60 tph) onto one track.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if the whole QBL (E)(F)(M)(R) is suspended(yes that includes the Archer Avenue/Hillside as well) because of a ruptured sewer pipe and there was a G/O from Woodside (7) to Flushing-Main Street on ALL tracks and the 63rd Street Line is closed because of 2nd Avenue Subway work requiring the WHOLE Line to be closed.

 

 

And there was no (J)(Z) from Jamaica Ctr. to Bway Junction due to construction and then from Myrtle to Broad Street

 

and the (A) was suspended from the Rockaways/Lefferts Bl. to Euclid Ave. making the (A) terminate at Euclid.

 

also no Myrtle Av (M) service

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if the whole QBL (E)(F)(M)(R) is suspended(yes that includes the Archer Avenue/Hillside as well) because of a ruptured sewer pipe and there was a G/O from Woodside (7) to Flushing-Main Street on ALL tracks and the 63rd Street Line is closed because of 2nd Avenue Subway work requiring the WHOLE Line to be closed.

 

 

And there was no (J)(Z) from Jamaica Ctr. to Bway Junction due to construction and then from Myrtle to Broad Street

 

and the (A) was suspended from the Rockaways/Lefferts Bl. to Euclid Ave. making the (A) terminate at Euclid.

 

also no Myrtle Av (M) service

 

 

Shutdown all the subway system. Go by bus or walking

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please take TPH into account. Wallyhorse: you can't fit the (4)(5)(6) (60 tph) onto one track.

 

That's what I get for doing it when I'm dead tired. :P

 

Revising what I wrote earlier, (6) terminates at 59th with some (6) service terminating at 86th. Use (4)/ (5) for Grand Central, 14th Street, Brooklyn Bridge and stations south. Everything else is unchanged from what I wrote in that post.

 

Anyway, on to the next scenario:

 

Clark St (2)(3) is impassable. Challenge: you can introduce no more than one additional transfer for people who normally take the (2)(3).

 

(2) terminates at 14th Street.

(3) runs with the (1) to South Ferry.

 

(4) extended all times to New Lots Avenue

(5) extended all times to Flatbush Avenue

 

Special OOS transfer available between 1/2/3 and (A)/ (C) at Chambers and Chambers-WTC respectively.

 

For Brooklyn, take the (1)/ (3) to South Ferry and switch to the (N)/ (R) there (Whitehall).

Edited by Wallyhorse
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if the whole QBL (E)(F)(M)(R) is suspended(yes that includes the Archer Avenue/Hillside as well) because of a ruptured sewer pipe and there was a G/O from Woodside (7) to Flushing-Main Street on ALL tracks and the 63rd Street Line is closed because of 2nd Avenue Subway work requiring the WHOLE Line to be closed.

 

 

And there was no (J)(Z) from Jamaica Ctr. to Bway Junction due to construction and then from Myrtle to Broad Street

 

and the (A) was suspended from the Rockaways/Lefferts Bl. to Euclid Ave. making the (A) terminate at Euclid.

 

also no Myrtle Av (M) service

 

 

(7) Suspended.

(A) Suspended.

(E) Suspended.

(F) Terminates at 57 Street.

(M) Suspended.

(J)(Z) Suspended.

(R) Terminates at Times Square-42 Street.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK...

 

Atlantic Avenue-Prospect Park on the (B)/ (Q) is closed. Trains can stop at Atlantic Avenue & Prospect Park.

Have Fun!

 

 

(B) VIA the (D) to Coney Island, regular service to Prospect Park.

 

(Q) VIA the (R) to 59 Street, (N) to Coney Island, regular service to Prospect Park.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

(B) VIA the (D) to Coney Island, regular service to Prospect Park.

 

(Q) VIA the (R) to 59 Street, (N) to Coney Island, regular service to Prospect Park.

 

 

What service will be on Brighton? *coughextend (S) cough*

 

(7) Suspended.

(A) Suspended.

(E) Suspended.

(F) Terminates at 57 Street.

(M) Suspended.

(J)(Z) Suspended.

(R) Terminates at Times Square-42 Street.

 

 

Also, (C) extended to 207 St with increased headways.

Edited by ThrexxBus
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Due to a busted sewer pipes, no trains can pass any Central Park West lines.

NO SHUTTLE BUSES.

 

 

Sure, but you never said no (S)'s did you.

 

(B)(D) to 34 Street (6 Av/Brighton/4 Av Express/West End Local)

(S) 161 St to 205 St (Grand CC Local)

(S) 168 St to 207 St (UWS Local)

(A) Times Square to Lefferts and Far Rockaway (8 Av/Fulton Local)

(C) No Service

Edited by trainguy97
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had in mind to terminate the (2) at Wall St - there is a crossover south of there (it's not shown on the track map).

 

That would give people the one extra transfer to the (4)(5) at Fulton St.

 

Thanks! I would have had the (2)/ (3) to Wall had I known that.

 

Anyway::

 

Atlantic Avenue-Prospect Park on the (B)/ (Q) is closed. Trains can stop at Atlantic Avenue & Prospect Park.

 

Since Botanic Garden seems to be able to handle 300' trains:

 

(B) runs as a loop to/from Prospect Park through Coney Island and then to/from 145th or Bedford Park Boulevard as follows:

Via the (N) to Manhattan (running express on Sea Beach) after running Prospect Park-Coney Island

Via the (D) to Brooklyn (running express through the West End, stopping at express stations Brooklyn-bound ONLY before going through Coney Island back to Prospect Park.

 

(Q) runs in two parts:

Ditmars Boulevard-Atlantic Avenue (regular platform)

Botanic Garden-Coney Island (this section as a reduced 300' train, stopping on Prospect Park-bound side)

For service to/from Atlantic Avenue to/from Prospect Park, take the (2)/ (3)/ (4)/ (5) between Atlantic-Pacific and Botanic Garden.

 

Franklin Avenue (S) operates ONLY between Franklin Avenue and Botanic Garden, terminating on the Franklin Avenue-bound track at Botanic Garden, transfer there to the (Q) on the opposite track for Prospect Park and points south.

 

Next:

The 72nd Street/CPW station is closed due to an issue in the Dakota Apartments that police are concerned could spread to the station below if it were open. The local track is unusable because of this, however, the local tracks north of there CAN be used, including the crossovers to/from the express tracks, which ARE usuable.throughout. Also, a separate issue has 59th Street-Columbus Circle closed with all trains (including the (1)) passing through the station, but not stopping.

Edited by Wallyhorse
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks! I would have had the (2)/ (3) to Wall had I known that.

 

Anyway::

 

 

 

Since Botanic Garden seems to be able to handle 300' trains:

 

(B) runs as a loop to/from Prospect Park through Coney Island and then to/from 145th or Bedford Park Boulevard as follows:

Via the (N) to Manhattan (running express on Sea Beach) after running Prospect Park-Coney Island

Via the (D) to Brooklyn (running express through the West End, stopping at express stations Brooklyn-bound ONLY before going through Coney Island back to Prospect Park.

 

(Q) runs in two parts:

Ditmars Boulevard-Atlantic Avenue (regular platform)

Botanic Garden-Coney Island (this section as a reduced 300' train, stopping on Prospect Park-bound side)

For service to/from Atlantic Avenue to/from Prospect Park, take the (2)/ (3)/ (4)/ (5) between Atlantic-Pacific and Botanic Garden.

 

Franklin Avenue (S) operates ONLY between Franklin Avenue and Botanic Garden, terminating on the Franklin Avenue-bound track at Botanic Garden, transfer there to the (Q) on the opposite track for Prospect Park and points south.

 

 

Why not just extend the (S) to Coney Island instead of having that weird (Q) train thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why not just extend the (S) to Coney Island instead of having that weird (Q) train thing.

 

The problem is, you would in that scenario need more than a 150' train to cover the part to Coney Island, plus because after Botanic Garden the (S) is single-tracked that creates its own problems.

 

This to me is a compromise for something like this, having part of a split (Q), reduced to 300' trains run via the shuttle tracks to Botanic Garden while a single (S) train runs the two stops between Botanic Garden and Franklin Avenue.

 

This is also where my previously suggested idea if they do rebuild the Franklin line anyway of going back to two tracks AND making all stations at least 480 (and preferably 600) feet would come in tremendously since as part of this, I would also build a connection between the existing Franklin Shuttle and remaining portion of the Myrtle Avenue Line (including a full rebuild of the upper level of Myrtle Avenue) for a new Myrtile-Brighton line (that I would call a "Black V") that can be a fuil-time local from Metropolitan to , plus for emergencies a connection from such line to the Broadway-Brooklyn line. In that scenario, the (B), if not running 75-foot cars could be run via that to the Broadway-Brooklyn line via the (M) and then after Essex resume normal Manhattan service while the (Q) in an emergency can also run via 6th Avenue.

 

With that said:

 

 

4 Av is out. GO.

 

(B) is suspended.

 

 

(D) runs as follows:

From 205th Street-Bronx via regular route to West 4th, then via the (F) to Coney Island (using the express tracks in both directions to Church Avenue and then (in the peak direction) via the elevated express track to Avenue X), then through Coney Island via regular route to 9th Avenue (the reverse is true to 205th Street).

 

(N) runs as follows:

From Ditmars Boulevard to Brighton Beach (replacing the (B) along the Brighton Line), then via the (Q) to Coney Island and then through Coney Island via regular route to 59th Street-4th Avenue, which would be the terminal and only station on 4th Avenue open (with the reverse true to Ditmars Boulevard).

 

(R) runs 71st Continental-Whitehall Street.

 

(Q) runs as a local in Brooklyn.

 

(R) Shuttle bus runs from 95th Street to Atlantic-Pacific.

 

Next:

The 72nd Street/CPW station is closed due to an issue in the Dakota Apartments that police are concerned could spread to the station below if it were open. The local track is unusable because of this, however, the local tracks north of there CAN be used, including the crossovers to/from the express tracks, which ARE usuable.throughout. Also, a separate issue has 59th Street-Columbus Circle closed with all trains (including the (1)) passing through the station, but not stopping. (I had posted this one earlier, but no one had responded to it).

Edited by Wallyhorse
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The 72nd Street/CPW station is closed due to an issue in the Dakota Apartments that police are concerned could spread to the station below if it were open. The local track is unusable because of this, however, the local tracks north of there CAN be used, including the crossovers to/from the express tracks, which ARE usuable.throughout. Also, a separate issue has 59th Street-Columbus Circle closed with all trains (including the (1)) passing through the station, but not stopping. (I had posted this one earlier, but no one had responded to it).

 

 

(B)(C) Trains skip 72 St. I think 32 tph can work in this case because there are no stations on the express track there.

 

NEXT

Because of a police investigation, the Eastern Pkwy express and Brighton tracks are closed and impassable in the vicinity of 7 Av. The local tracks are fine.

 

Reroute (4)(5)(B)(Q) trains, keeping tph in account. Please avoid through-running or extending the (S)...it's not realistic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Lance

(5) - no service btwn Bowling Green and Brooklyn College (use (2) trains instead)

(4) - local in both direction btwn Atlantic Av & Franklin Av

(B) - via West End in both directions to Stillwell Av

(Q) - via Sea Beach in both directions to Stillwell Av

shuttle trains run from Coney Island (Brighton platforms) to Prospect Park (local only)

for 7 Av, use nearby Grand Army Plaza (Eastern Pkwy)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.