Skipper,
What's the market there? Those who want downtown access can take the already...
The service only makes sense if a Staten island link gets built.
________________
Bobthepanda,
Yes, I agree they should be subways, but a. Cost and B. Surprisingly few people from those areas commute to Manhattan. It'd be better as a part of a LRT network that serves outer Queens/inner Nassau, funneling passengers to the LIRR in conjunction with freedom ticket.
And yes, I know I'm getting waaaay ahead of myself...