Jump to content

Subway - What If?


VWM

Recommended Posts

(5) trains are extended from Nereid Avenue to Wakefield-241 Street.

 

There, I think...

 

Good. No fowm.

NEXT:

Due to an emergency, the West 4 Street-Washington Square station is impassible on both levels.

Affected: (A)(B)(C)(D)(E)(F)(M)

 

Another one, purposely made to do with the above one. Otherwise, if lazy, do it separate.

Due to another emergency, the Kew Gardens-Union Turnpike station is also impassible, including the lower level (layups, yard tracks, etc.)

Affected: (E)(F)(M)(R)

 

I'll do the second one since the first one has been done so much already:

(E) WTC - Queens Plaza or 71 Av

(F) Coney Island - 71 Av

(M) Metropolitan Av - Queens Plaza OR Chambers St

(R) normal route except: trains use different switches at 71 Av, and some trains terminate at 57 St/7 Av

 

Jamaica riders are advised to use buses or the (J) and (Z) trains.

 

NEXT: Due to a huge event near Atlantic Av-Barclays Center, service must be maximized to that area.

 

Rules:

 

1. No fowming. Come up with useful routes that benefit riders; extending the (J)(Z) to South Brooklyn is not one of them.

2. No careless solutions like "increase service on all lines", which isn't even possible due to capacity and fleet constraints.

3. You can't use spare trains to increase service, or buy more trains from Bombardier :lol:. To make a line run more frequently, you have to either modify the route (short-turns, for example) or take trains from another line.

 

Have fun guys!

Edited by TheSubwayStation
Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Replies 6.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Another one, purposely made to do with the above one. Otherwise, if lazy, do it separate.

Due to another emergency, the Kew Gardens-Union Turnpike station is also impassible, including the lower level (layups, yard tracks, etc.)

Affected: (E)(F)(M)(R)

 

 

(E): b/w Lexington Avenue and 71st Street, using the express tracks to terminate.

(F): No trains b/w 34th Street and 2nd Avenue and b/w 21st Street and 179th Street.

(M): No trains b/w Essex Street and 71st Street.

(R): No trains b/w Queensboro Plaza (some trains are rerouted to Astoria, others terminate at 57th Street) and 71st Street.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT: Due to a huge event near Atlantic Av-Barclays Center, service must be maximized to that area.

Have fun guys!

 

 

(B)(D) Select trains terminate at Broadway-Laffayette or West 4 Street.

(N)(Q)(R) Select trains terminate at Whitehall Street, Times Square-42 Street or 57 Street-7 Avenue.

(D)(R) Select trains terminate at 9 Avenue.

(N)(R) Select trains terminate at 59 Street.

(J)(Z)SELECT trains are extended to 9 Avenue.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

(F): No trains b/w 34th Street and 2nd Avenue and b/w 21st Street and 179th Street.

 

That doesn't work, unfortunately.

 

(B)(D) Select trains terminate at Broadway-Laffayette or West 4 Street.

(N)(Q)(R) Select trains terminate at Whitehall Street, Times Square-42 Street or 57 Street-7 Avenue.

(D)(R) Select trains terminate at 9 Avenue.

(N)(R) Select trains terminate at 59 Street.

 

Terminating trains at Whitehall, Broadway-Lafayette, or W 4 St is a bad idea IMO because people coming from further uptown in Manhattan won't have increased service to Atlantic Av-Barclays Center. Edited by TheSubwayStation
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT: Due to a huge event near Atlantic Av-Barclays Center, service must be maximized to that area.

 

Rules:

 

1. No fowming. Come up with useful routes that benefit riders; extending the (J)(Z) to South Brooklyn is not one of them.

2. No careless solutions like "increase service on all lines", which isn't even possible due to capacity and fleet constraints.

3. You can't use spare trains to increase service, or buy more trains from Bombardier :lol:. To make a line run more frequently, you have to either modify the route (short-turns, for example) or take trains from another line.

 

Have fun guys!

 

 

Ok, here's a list of thing's I'll do. Let's hypothetically say the Nets make it to the NBA Finals... :lol:

 

1. Some (1) trains are extended to Utica Avenue (aproxx. 6 TPH). If there are space constraints at Rogers Junction, then trains terminate at Atlantic Avenue.

2. Queens bound (A) trains stop at Lafayette Avenue.

3. (B) service is extended overnight.

4. Special (D) and (N) trains terminate at Pacific Street southbound. Other (D) and (N) trains make local stops to allow for these trains to terminate at Pacific Street.

 

That's what I came up with....

 

(B)(D) Select trains terminate at Broadway-Laffayette or West 4 Street.

(N)(Q)(R) Select trains terminate at Whitehall Street, Times Square-42 Street or 57 Street-7 Avenue.

(D)(R) Select trains terminate at 9 Avenue.

(N)(R) Select trains terminate at 59 Street.

(J)(Z) SELECT trains are extended to 9 Avenue.

 

 

PicardDoubleFacepalm-1.jpg?1316330080

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(E): b/w Lexington Avenue and 71st Street, using the express tracks to terminate.

(F): No trains b/w 34th Street and 2nd Avenue and b/w 21st Street and 179th Street.

(M): No trains b/w Essex Street and 71st Street.

(R): No trains b/w Queensboro Plaza (some trains are rerouted to Astoria, others terminate at 57th Street) and 71st Street.

 

 

2 things:

1 - LOL, You keep on saying 71st STREET instead of 71st AVENUE.

2 - Why are you suspending trains to Jackson Heights- it's Kew Gardens-Union Turnpike.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 things:

1 - You keep on saying 71st STREET instead of 71st AVENUE.

2 - Why are you suspending trains to Jackson Heights- it's Kew Gardens-Union Turnpike + layups, yard tracks.

 

 

Amendment:

 

Select (R) and (F) trains terminate at Jackson Heights.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WTF? What's wrong with extending (1) trains to Brooklyn? You wanted more service, you GOT IT....

 

The fact that I'm almost 100% sure that Bway/7 Av riders will instinctively wait for a (2) or (3) even if a (1) train pulls in saying "Utica Av". Those (1) trains will be empty, just like sending random (J) trains to 9 Av...And terminating trains at Atlantic Avenue when there are other trains coming through on the same tracks is BAD.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The fact that I'm almost 100% sure that Bway/7 Av riders will instinctively wait for a (2) or (3) even if a (1) train pulls in saying "Utica Av". Those (1) trains will be empty, just like sending random (J) trains to 9 Av...And terminating trains at Atlantic Avenue when there are other trains coming through on the same tracks is BAD.

 

 

Well where do you expect the trains to come from? So you're saying that people would get on if it was labled as a (2), but not as a (1)???? New Yorkers aren't THAT STUPID....

 

What the **** has happened to this thread.

 

 

IDEK....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT:

Due to an emergency, the West 4 Street-Washington Square station is impassible on both levels.

Affected: (A)(B)(C)(D)(E)(F)(M)

 

Another one, purposely made to do with the above one. Otherwise, if lazy, do it separate.

Due to another emergency, the Kew Gardens-Union Turnpike station is also impassible, including the lower level (layups, yard tracks, etc.)

Affected: (E)(F)(M)(R)

 

 

(E) Runs in two sections:

Jamaica Center to Van Wyck Blvd.

75 Avenue to 14 Street, via QB Local - 8 Ave Express.

 

(F) Runs in three sections:

179 Street to Van Wyck Blvd, single-tracked.

75 Avenue to 34 Street-Herald Square, via QB Local.

Delancy Street to Coney Island.

 

(M)(R) No service b/w 71 Avenue & Queens Plaza.

 

Since yard tracks are not accessible, trains layup on the express tracks.

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Is this the first thread to get to page 100?

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEW SCENARIOS!!!

 

Easy - Due to an outage in Bay Ridge no trains can run south of Bay Ridge Avenue on the 4th Avenue line. Lines that need reroutings: (R)

 

Easy - 145th Street is impassible. Lines that need reroutings: (3)

 

Easy - Sterling Street is impassible. Lines that need reroutings: (2)(5)

 

Medium - No trains can terminate at Forest Hills - 71st Avenue. The (R) and (M) must have the same TPH to Queens, reroute away.

 

Medium - The 14th Street tube is blocked, reroute (L) trains with creating minimal delays.

 

Medium - Broadway Junction is impassible on the (J) and (Z) trains.

 

Hard - No trains can pass on the express track at 86th Street. Reroute the (4) and (5) trains.

 

Hard - Avenue M on the Brighton Line is impassible in all directions. Provide Kings Hwy with train service.

 

Extra Service - The Knicks are playing at MSG, which is at Penn Station. Provide the 34th Street - Penn Station Stops with extra service.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT: Due to a huge event near Atlantic Av-Barclays Center, service must be maximized to that area.

 

Rules:

 

1. No fowming. Come up with useful routes that benefit riders; extending the (J)(Z) to South Brooklyn is not one of them.

2. No careless solutions like "increase service on all lines", which isn't even possible due to capacity and fleet constraints.

3. You can't use spare trains to increase service, or buy more trains from Bombardier :lol:. To make a line run more frequently, you have to either modify the route (short-turns, for example) or take trains from another line.

 

Have fun guys!

 

 

There would be rush hour service, even if it's not actually rush hour. Therefore the (5) would terminate at Flatbush while the (Q) would run to Coney Island.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well where do you expect the trains to come from? So you're saying that people would get on if it was labled as a (2), but not as a (1)???? New Yorkers aren't THAT STUPID....

 

 

Actually that's precisely correct. If I was trying to go to Brooklyn and a (1) train pulled up, I wouldn't get on that even if I saw the signs said that it was going to Utica Av or Flatbush because the correct thing that most New Yorkers would assume is that the sign is broken. Even if the station agents made an announcement over the intercom most people still wouldn't be on it because those things are practically undecipherable and nobody can ever understand what they're saying.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEW SCENARIOS!!!

 

Easy - Due to an outage in Bay Ridge no trains can run south of Bay Ridge Avenue on the 4th Avenue line. Lines that need reroutings: (R)

Easy - 145th Street is impassible. Lines that need reroutings: (3)

Easy - Sterling Street is impassible. Lines that need reroutings: (2)(5)

Medium - No trains can terminate at Forest Hills - 71st Avenue. The (R) and (M) must have the same TPH to Queens, reroute away.

Medium - The 14th Street tube is blocked, reroute (L) trains with creating minimal delays.

Medium - Broadway Junction is impassible on the (J) and (Z) trains.

Hard - No trains can pass on the express track at 86th Street. Reroute the (4) and (5) trains.

Hard - Avenue M on the Brighton Line is impassible in all directions. Provide Kings Hwy with train service.

 

 

I DID IT COMBINED!!!

 

(2) Via Eastern Parkway Local to New Lots Avenue.

(3) No service b/w 135 Street & 148 Street.

(4) Via Lexington Avenue Local b/w 42 Street & 125 Street.

(5) Via Eastern Parkway Express to Utica Avenue. Via Clark Street/7th Avenue Local.

 

(B) No service b/w Church Avenue & Brighton Beach.

(D) Select trains extended to Kings Highway via Brighton Express.

(F) Via Hillside Avenue Express.

(J)(Z) No service b/w Chauncey Street & Alabama Avenue.

(L) No service b/w Bedford Avenue & 3 Avenue.

(M)(R) Extended to Jamaica-179 Street, via Hillside Local.

(N) Extended to Kings Highway via Brighton Local.

(Q) No service b/w Church Avenue & Coney Island. Single-tracked shuttles run b/w Parkside Avenue & Avenue J.

Edited by TrainFanInfinity
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well where do you expect the trains to come from? So you're saying that people would get on if it was labled as a (2), but not as a (1)???? New Yorkers aren't THAT STUPID....

 

Yes, they are. And I don't blame them. If you're not a buff, you probably don't read the signs (understandably) because every other (1) train you've ever been on hasn't gone to Brooklyn.

 

Okay, I'll solve my scenario:

(2) select trains terminate at 96 St using the (1) line's middle track. Select (2) trains terminate at Utica/New Lots Avs.

(3)possibly select uptown trains can terminate at 34 St - Penn Station. (I guess some (2) trains can do this too.)

(A) Manhattan bound trains stop at Lafayette Av. Queens bound trains run local from Hoyt-Schermerhorn to Utica Av.

(B)(Q) select trains terminate at Prospect Park

(N)(Q) select trains terminate at 57 St/7 Av

(D)(N)(R) select trains terminate at Atlantic Av; other (D)(N) trains run local on 4 Av.

Edited by TheSubwayStation
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NO.NO.NO.

 

What the **** has happened to this thread.

 

 

It is like we got some weed up in this b*tch.

 

1. Some (1) trains are extended to Utica Avenue (aproxx. 6 TPH). If there are space constraints at Rogers Junction, then trains terminate at Atlantic Avenue.

 

 

I would get suspended for posting the text of this meme.

 

tumblr_m67ijv0Kla1qizx4p.png

 

NEXT

Due to a smoke condition, Atlantic Av (2)(3)(4)<5> is impassible. Go ahead. And remember this is SMOKE.

Edited by Brighton Express
Link to comment
Share on other sites

NEXT

Due to a smoke condition, Atlantic Av (2)(3)(4)<5> is impassible. Go ahead. And remember this is SMOKE.

From all the weed that Threxx is smoking :lol:?

 

Okay, here we go:

(2) Flatbush Av - Eastern Pkwy

(3) New Lots Av - Eastern Pkwy

(4) and (5) trains that are in service past Atlantic Av should be converted to (2) and (3) trains.

 

(4) Woodlawn - Borough Hall

(5) Dyre/Nereid Av - Bowling Green

 

(2)(3) terminates in Manhattan at either 14 St or Wall St. Downtown trains terminating at Wall St run local from 34 St to Chambers St so as not to interfere with trains terminating on the downtown express track at 14 St.

 

(N) trains run via tunnel to provide a transfer at Borough Hall

Edited by TheSubwayStation
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Actual solution to the above scenario:

 

(2) and (5): No trains b/w Manhattan and Atlantic Avenue (all trains in Brooklyn are labeled as (5))

(3) and (4): No trains b/w Borough Hall and Atlantic Avenue (all trains in Brooklyn are labeled as (4))

Edited by Threxx
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.