Your point taken, that yes, it's inaccurate to act like the depot got built there out of spite after a major community was established. But, to be fair, it's not like everybody moving up to Harlem in the 1940s/50s did that entirely by choice. It was an extremely low-cost neighborhood for poor people (most of them black) to move, so many went. I'm sure plenty of people would have preferred to live on the Upper East Side, but whatwith the sheer property value and redlining, that wasn't really an option. And if you do look at some of the depots in more residential, wealthier neighborhoods (Hudson Depot or 54th Street Depot, for example), the TA has since shuttered/repurposed those garages and moved the vehicles out. It's not a total coincidence that the remaining bus depots in Manhattan are in neighborhoods with less political say and sway (exception Quill, which is in tunnel no man's land). I agree that it was complete BS when Clayton Guse tried this argument about RTSes at ENY (as if the M66/72 were running through impoverished neighborhoods), and you're right that the line gets thrown around in some silly ways, but in this case it's not completely out of left field.